The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) outlined a draft framework on December 11, 2017, to coordinate oversight of internet service providers (ISPs) amid the planned removal of net neutrality protections. The agreement comes as the FCC prepares to vote on a proposal viewed by many critics as a step toward deregulation of the internet.

Under the proposed plan, the FCC would oversee consumer complaints related to ISPs, focusing particularly on transparency issues. This includes evaluating whether ISPs are accurately disclosing potentially harmful practices such as content blocking or throttling. On the other hand, the FTC’s role would be to investigate these disclosures to verify their accuracy and ensure consumers are fully informed about ISPs’ practices.
The upcoming FCC vote is expected to favor the end of net neutrality rules, enabling ISPs to self-regulate. The FCC’s draft, dubbed the "Internet Freedom Order," aims to foster innovation and investment by reducing regulatory constraints. Supporters of the plan argue that more leeway for ISPs will lead to better services and infrastructure development.
Critics, however, warn that allowing ISPs to regulate themselves could lead to harmful practices that go unchecked. Consumer advocacy groups point out that ISPs have historically been ranked among the least trusted companies in the nation, often accused of deceptive or unfair practices that compromise consumer rights. Concerns extend to the possibility of prioritizing certain internet traffic over others, potentially impacting free speech and equitable access.
The partnership between the FCC and FTC reflects an attempt to address these issues, but skepticism remains. Critics argue that merely monitoring disclosures and relying on ISPs’ transparency may not be sufficient to prevent abuse. Many believe that expecting companies known for prioritizing profits over consumer interests to self-regulate effectively is unrealistic.
As debate continues, the shifting regulatory landscape raises questions about the future of internet access in the U.S. The move to transfer regulatory duties from the FCC to the FTC, coupled with deregulation efforts, could fundamentally alter how consumers experience online services, possibly leading to less uniform and equitable access.
The upcoming vote will be a pivotal moment for internet regulation, with observers watching closely to see how this new collaborative approach will influence consumer protections and industry practices in a rapidly evolving digital environment.
Corrections and clarifications: contact@avorz.com
How this was reported: /how-we-report/