The New York Times has initiated legal action against the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to obtain information related to potential foreign interference in its public comment process on net neutrality. The lawsuit seeks to compel the FCC to disclose data that could reveal Russian involvement in tampering with comments submitted during the agency's open feedback period.

The controversy stems from the FCC's handling of a surge in comments during the public feedback phase in May 2017, when over 22 million submissions were received. Technical issues plagued the comment platform, initially blamed on hacking but later attributed to system overload, partly due to increased public interest after a segment on John Oliver's show.
Suspicions grew as reports emerged of numerous comments appearing suspicious—featuring repetitive language, unverified email addresses, and fake or deceased names. These concerns prompted investigations into whether foreign actors, specifically Russian operatives, manipulated the comment process.
A key catalyst was an op-ed by FCC member Jessica Rosenworcel, suggesting that hundreds of thousands of comments may have originated from Russian email accounts. Further analysis identified links between email addresses in the Mueller Report and those used during the comment period. Estimates indicated that about 500,000 comments could be tied to Russian sources, with an additional eight million created through disposable email services.
Despite these alarms, the FCC has consistently refused to provide full access to records that could confirm foreign interference. The New York Times' Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, filed since July 2017, have been met with repeated denials, with the agency citing concerns over IT security and recent court rulings limiting the disclosure of certain server logs.
The FOIA requests, now narrowed to specific data points—namely IP addresses, timestamps, and user-agent headers—aim to clarify the origin and timing of comments. The Times argues that such transparency is vital to understanding the extent of foreign influence on a process that directly impacted a major policy decision on net neutrality.
The FCC maintains that releasing these details could compromise its cybersecurity protocols, emphasizing that legal rulings do not compel the disclosure of certain server logs. However, some legal experts note that the ruling also affirmed the need to release email addresses and documentation relevant to public comments, which could support the NYT’s case.
This legal confrontation underscores broader concerns about foreign interference in U.S. democratic processes. The outcome may set important precedents regarding access to data, transparency, and protections against external influence in American rule-making.
As proceedings continue, the public's right to scrutinize government transparency versus the FCC's security concerns remains a central issue. The case could influence future policies on how agencies manage and disclose comment records, especially in cases involving national security and foreign meddling.
Corrections and clarifications: contact@avorz.com
How this was reported: /how-we-report/